Proving that he continues finding ways to stoop to new lows, Luke Wenke suggests in the following letter that innocent children are to blame for unwanted correspondence his victims received. He claims that he allowed clients’ children to play games on his phone while transporting patients to and from medical appointments, stating, “Hopefully no child maliciously abused emails or social media platforms on my phone.”
Luke Wenke’s Batch of Lies
Per usual, Luke Wenke fixates on me throughout the letter. He tells numerous lies, including that I had exclusive access to the discovery paperwork from his first cyberstalking case. He claims that I saw his discovery documents before his own family did, but I’ve never seen Wenke’s discovery, period.
Also in accordance with his typical behavior, Wenke falsely accuses me of stealing his car, burglarizing/vandalizing his dilapidated house, being on drugs, and of violating his privacy rights with my website’s content. He also indicates that his public defender supposedly has juicy “dirt” on me, which is, again, straight-up false.
If Luke Wenke had access to any of the details of what’s happened in my life over the last seven-plus years, he wouldn’t constantly obsess over men I dated over a decade ago. He thinks and talks about my exes more than I do, and it’s fucking disturbing.
Either way, Wenke is clearly working with outdated information, because that’s all that’s available to him. Wenke also thinks he knows where I live, what I do for a living, and my socioeconomic status, and he’s wildly off-base with his assessments. But I think he knows this and doesn’t care that he’s not being factual. I think he simply tries to make me look bad at every opportunity, thinking (or at least hoping) that he can scare me back into silence and misery.
Mommy’s Alleged Cease & Desist Order
One of the most egregious lies Luke Wenke tells about me in the following letter is that I violated a cease and desist order that is supposedly “in place” courtesy of his mother. To my knowledge, I have not received a “cease and desist” letter from Luke Wenke’s mother. She tried sending me a certified letter at a relative’s house, but I don’t live there and I’m unwilling to engage in any form of contact with her, so I told the mailman to return the letter to sender. I never opened the letter.
Secondly, sending a cease and desist letter doesn’t mean it’s binding or valid. I learned this the hard way when I sent Luke Wenke a cease and desist letter in 2022. I mailed the letter to the Niagara County Jail, where he was being held in custody for his first cyberstalking case. Because I didn’t send the letter via certified mail, I couldn’t prove that Wenke received it, which meant that I couldn’t prove that he was aware that I wanted to be left alone.
But the most outrageous lie of them all, at least in this letter, is that my arrest history is “much more volatile” than Luke Wenke’s. It’s not. I was last arrested well over a decade ago for nonviolent charges that were ultimately dismissed. I have no felony or misdemeanor convictions on my record; Luke Wenke is a federally convicted felonious stalker who is now facing a second cyberstalking charge.
Meanwhile, Wenke whines like a little bitch in this letter about how the FBI arrested him at gunpoint and gave him a boo-boo on the head just a few months ago. I’ve never been held at gunpoint by law enforcement, nor have the police ever injured me in the process of apprehending me. I’ve never been tackled, screamed at, physically restrained, threatened with force, or anything of the like.
All Luke Wenke seems to do is lie, but I’m going to interpret this as a good sign that he doesn’t have a leg to stand on in civil court and that his bullshit lawsuit will be tossed into the trash where it belongs.
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Letter
February 27th, 2026
CASE #1:26-cv-00181, DKT. #6
To read a “transcribed” version of this letter, scroll past the PDF viewer. 🙂
Wenke v. Valentine – Letter – Doc. #6 – 02/27/2026Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 1:
“Hello to the Office of Judge Vilardo,
“If my estimates are correct, the entire Robert H. Jackson US Courthouse is aware of who I am by now, otherwise I would not have been thrown all the way out to Rochester as if I am one big conflict of interest for Buffalo to continue dealing with. Yes I was the Cattaraugus County Libertarian Chairman at one point in time, but more importantly it is crucial that you remember calling me ‘Judge Carolyn Giardini’s oldest grandson’ is a literal statement. My maternal grandmother Carolyn Jane Panada Giardini was the Justice of the Peace for Carrollton, NY. Family members of judges, let alone in their own country, in the format the Robert H. Jackson US Courthouse has seen me since 2022 in my opinion is a paradoxical sociology crisis.
“I am aware that a Magistrate deals with Pro Se litigation circumstances first and foremost. However I have Judge Vilardo’s name on my most recent paperwork, so here I am sending this accordingly. Hopefully you are aware of the fact that US District Judge John Sinatra sent me confidential legal mail recently right here to Monroe County Jail. The prosecutor to the present circumstances, S. Eldridge, is fuming over the fact that he cannot legally see any of the content that was sent to me. I sent evidence of my claims to my mother Janet McCaul of [address], so hopefully she received every paper I sent her without any intrusion. I have also been keeping the Office of US Appeals Judge Debra Ann Livingston informed on my end of things. Update; my mother’s mail was interfered with.
“I would like to give you the history of my circumstances in my own…”
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 2:
“…words now that I am a plaintiff at last. As if I didn’t put any thought into making Andrew Clark and Katie [last name] codefendants. Yes I did, and it didn’t take long either.
“I’ve known Katie since 2010 from Bruyer’s Martial Arts of Olean, and I have known Andrew since summer 2020 when I was responsibly reporting Hamas’s presence out in Minneapolis provoking racial tensions. The last 4+ years on my end of things should make everybody question ever trusting either of these two ever again. It is Fonda Kubiak who told my mother that Katie is employed by Buffalo federal probation these days.
“January 2022 I was reporting my former neighbor Amber [last name]’s household to the Olean Police, and I was even able to get state senator George Borrello to release a statement to the media to end the eviction ban as Amber’s household was one of many abusing that. Andrew encouraged the Olean Police to lie to me over a 1/27/22 phone call while I was driving for Lyft in Buffalo, ‘Come help us with your neighbor tomorrow’ said the Olean Police to me. I showed up the next day since I was a concerned homeowner. Around the corner comes Andrew and Krystie of the Buffalo FBI who knew me a year and a half beforehand, very aggressively giving me no choice but to go into the car with them.
“I was not on my way out to Minneapolis to do anything to anybody. I was first intending to take care of my neighborhood issues via the Olean Police, and then next up to Buffalo for another day driving for Lyft.
“It’s been over 4 years since. Andrew was with Paul of the US…”
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 3:
“…Marshals where I was December 2025 making fun of the fact that I know my USM/BOP number by memory. So Andrew is now a Defendant. January 2022 had he came to talk to me about what to do to really take care of my neighborhood’s issues, I would have cooperated even if it meant setting up Amber in a drug entrapment. In the 4 years since, I have been behind quite a few drug busts within jail/prison walls. But anyways, Andrew is untrustworthy. He was aggressive at my mother’s house the day after I came to Monroe County Jail. He should know better because he met her all that time ago, too.
“Onto Katie. Victoria Bahl of the Rochester Federal Public Defender’s Office has all kinds of details on [ex-husband]’s long ago exwife Katie [lastname]. Not even Marianne Mariano can deny the fact that Katie had my FBI Discovery two days after I got to Niagara County Jail in 2022. It took over a month for me to get this one in 2026. My mother currently has a cease and desist order against Katie’s website lukewenke.online and her Facebook page The Luke Wenke Files where she cyberstalked me for over a year, and for some reason the Buffalo Federal Public Defender’s Office did nothing to stop her from publishing on those platforms. Victoria Bahl is also happy to admit that Katie somehow had full and immediate access to John Sinatra’s courtroom emails. I advise all men to be wary of [ex-husband]’s exwife Katie [last name] because Katie very proudly and openly paid for New York University tuition by placing herself on personal ads soliciting herself out to married wealthy men. [Person I haven’t spoken to since 2018], [person I haven’t spoken to since 2021], and many more out there can testify to Katie completely ruining Pat [ex-boyfriend whom I dated in 2013 for two months]’s life after getting a free car out of him. Lastly, spring 2022 Katie decided to get my Ford car…”
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 4:
“…repo’d at Professional Recovery without my permission and this move from Katie caused damaged turmoil to my credit via Wells Fargo. My mother has been in touch with the owner of Professional Recovery and he has been more than ready to testify remembering Katie. Spring 2022 it was originally on NY Troopers to look into what Katie did to my car, as NY Troopers told my mother they would be ready to get Katie for grand theft auto if the car was ever found. NY Troopers went to see Katie and I was told that a report was written up that Katie appeared drugged up and mental at the front door. Victoria is the one who told me there is a 5 year statute of limitations on grand theft auto. How wonderful it would be to finally get Katie on grand theft auto via the Rochester FBI so Katie can be placed under duress and answer questions concerning why the Buffalo Federal Public Defender’s Office is covering for whoever wrecked the inside of my house in Olean while I was at FMC Devens. Rochester seems to believe Katie and [Wenke’s former probation officer] were involved. I had Officer Cottone of the Olean Police report on the damaged inside of my house, and Katie was very openly nervous on her websites on me when she learned I still have it in me to responsibly call police. It’s also worth noting that September 2023, Katie lied to the [city] Police about me. Katie also has a much more volatile arrest history than I ever did.
“There’s your rundown on the history I have with Andrew and Katie. Deuteronomy 19:16 with Andrew and Katie the liars. Perhaps I should root for the idea of Kash Patel firing Andrew and Katie getting civilly confined over my car, her websites, and perhaps even evidence against my house if it turns out she was in fact behind it. So many years of…”
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 5:
“…elongated animosity could have been avoided if those two new how to speak to me like mature adults. They don’t, so I made them defendants.
“Onto this particular infraction. It is time to completely abolish ‘cyberstalking’ off the 18 USCS criminal code for so many reasons.
“First of all, Katie’s internet activity cyberstalked me for over a year. Unfortunately I can’t call 911 from a jail/prison phone, and unfortunately the Buffalo Federal Public Defender’s Office was not helping stop her internet activity against me. Secondly, I recall telling Andrew and Krystie in the car on the way up to Niagara County Jail January 2022 that Uber was a Russian owned company, and once I received my 2022 FBI Discovery (which Katie had first), I recall seeing all kinds of evidence that my phone had been hacked through my Uber driver profile.
“This time around, the Wifi was mysteriously shut off at my mother’s house on [address] before I left to drive to Family Dollar of Salamanca, where I wound up cornered at gun point by FBI agents who answer to Andrew. I don’t know if they took the opportunity to hack my phone and download a bunch of apps on my iCloud account which they then deleted from homescreen visibility and continued to operate without my seeing it.
“Counterman v. Colorado 600 US 66 is a June 2023 US Supreme Court decision concerning infractions like this one. We are a nation of many English accents; from northern Yankee talk to southern howdy y’all vocabularies, from Harvard Ivy League…”
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 6:
“…prep school formalities to rap culture street talk, the very nature of what could be defined as ‘threatening language’ could differ from sea to shining sea. I don’t think the potential concept of somebody’s phone getting hacked and sending out an email to a US District Judge’s courtroom suggesting a lawsuit over their wrecked and damaged house is a criminal issue on behalf of the accused ‘cyberstalker’.
“Again, NY Troopers don’t charge at someone over a speech issue like this. Every time an email or social media post is sent out in my name, I’m supposed to live in fear that I might be cornered at gunpoint by FBI agents who as far as I’m concerned are no different than what I read about ICE? My present issue goes from Erie County to Cattaraugus County. A simple order of protection summons isn’t sufficient? I would sue over it anyways suggesting Katie is behind all the paperwork from John Sinatra. Andrew can’t get his FBI cronies to simply come talk to me rather than aim guns at me in the Salamanca Family Dollar parking lot? Should we expect those same agents to be behind the scenes at the US Marshals before a court hearing and point guns at me forcing me to admit guilt to a bunch of emails and social media posts nobody saw me send out? I remember allowing Skyy Homes Medical Transportation customers to let their children play games on my phone while I drove them to medical appointments. Hopefully no child maliciously abused emails or social media platforms on my phone while I was focusing on the road.
“Allow me to finish up this letter to the courtroom of Judge Vilardo by jumpstarting you on even further solutions to the public safety concerns…”
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 7:
UPPER MARGIN: “Unless ‘cyberstalking’ is completely removed from the criminal code, I plan on pursuing anybody and everybody’s cyberstalking arrest courtesy the Rochester FBI if they say one thing against me online, even if it’s a fake profile claiming to be them. If I have to live in fear from now on when I go on the internet, so should everyone else.”
“…of ‘threats’ cases like this. Let’s also recall the long distance concerns of this infraction. Do we want semi-truck drivers for McDonalds in California to hack the Bluetooth devices of semi-truck drivers for Burger King in Maine and make false claims of interstate threats and cyberstalking allegedly taking place so they can get the semi-truck drivers of the competing company maliciously arrested for the speech allegations? No we do not. This is a country where someone who did 48 years in prison came out innocent early 2024. Prevent anymore arrests like mine where the defendant is screamed at by a prosecutor making false claims of violence at the defendant.
“Siemens Dresser Rand of Olean is the solution to this issue. Public safety drones, public safety satellites orbiting the Earth, traffic cameras on telephone poles, and long distance towing is how to supervise an infraction like this long distance. If someone in Minnesota is ever again afraid of someone in Buffalo, the public safety technology mentioned up above can easily find that person in Buffalo. If the person in Buffalo drives out to Minnesota, once they make it to the would be victim’s county of residence, AI notifies the local police to show up and watchout for any physical activity that may take place.
“No more $45,000 per year per ‘threats’ inmate off the taxpayers. No more time wasted over conflicting and worthless psychological analyses; orders of protection don’t come with medical mandates. Last I knew, Congressman Nick Langworthy got a 78 year old military veteran for making ‘threats’ arrested. I met two more military veterans at FMC Devens, both cellmates of mine, Richard Little…”
Wenke v. Valentine et al. | Page 8:
UPPER MARGIN: “Another update for you since I pre-wrote this to your court. Karen Francati of the Rochester Federal Public Defender’s Office has evidence of Katie [last name] posting on the internet about this very lawsuit. This is obstruction of justice and this is a cyberstalking incident worthy of HER arrest. Also a violation of a cease and desist that is against her.”
“…and Justin Taraskewich, who were in for ‘threatening the VA’. If US military veterans are to find themselves incarcerated in their own country, I see paradoxical issues. I recall Allenwood prison having a POWMIA flag flying outside. Charles Manson was sentenced by a jury to the gas chamber in the 1970s. 2026 sure is a phony 250th with imprisoned military veterans over speech.
“Do we want Iran and Hamas provoking ‘international threats’ arrests against Jewish Americans? Do we want Elon Musk to get arrested for ‘interplanetary threats’ while he ‘cyberstalks’ an Earthbound Mark Zuckerberg from Mars?
“It is inmate gossip for me to say in writing from Monroe County Jail that Senior District Judge Richard Arcara wants to sentence people up to a collective one million years in his courtroom before he ever retires. Is he using my handwriting style to certify judgments in favor of the plaintiff? Katie [last name]’s previously talked about grand theft auto circumstances should go to HIS courtroom. Put her in Orleans County Jail as a fed case, too. She will help make Orleans County Jail’s Officer Ashberry the money he needs for the air conditioner he wanted in his office in 2024. What’s HER mental diagnosis?
“Hopefully this letter speeds things up for Wenke vs. Clark & Valentine,
“-Judge Giardini’s oldest grandson Luke Marshal Wenke”
